comic reviews
essential TPBs
character essays
event essays
other
comic links



The Much Happier State of Marvel
08.28.02

by:
Troy Brownfield

For the last couple of years, I've charted the state of Marvel. The biggest shift came when Joe Quesada became Editor-in-Chief. While I don't always agree with what he may say in press releases, there is no doubt that this man is a creative house of fire. By pulling in notable creators and pushing bold initiatives like the Ultimate line, he's catapulted some previously dull Marvel titles into things worth talking about again. Let's take a look at the highlights.

The X-Titles:

As Marvel's hot spot, the X-titles are always ripe for discussion. Creative teams shifted all over the place in '01 and early '02, and some promising projects, like The Brotherhood, were lost for various reasons. Obviously, Origin was a mammoth hit. X-Treme X-Men, after what I felt were slow early issues, seems to have found a voice.

As for Uncanny, the initial team of Joe Casey and Ian Churchill has already departed, but some solid stories are being told and the book is spot-on in entertainment value. I like the composition of the team, and again, I was very happy to see Chamber in a prominent role. Check out the "Poptopia" trade for the introductory arc. A new creative team of Chuck Austen and the talented Ron Garney are coming aboard; that could be quite nice.

The real triumphs of the line are now X-Statix (formerly X-Force) and New X-Men. Milligan and Allred took their dissection of fame and pop culture itself to new levels, and created a genuine fan favorite with the bizarre Doop. As for New X-Men, with Morrison at the helm, it's pound for pound one of the most inventive super-hero titles of the last decade. It's prime stuff, with two trades already making the rounds. Definitely look into it.

The Ultimates: Ultimate Spider-Man and Ultimate X-Men have been supremely entertaining. I've always been a fan of "reimaginings", and the creative prowess of writers Brian Michael Bendis and Mark Millar has been on full display. The shocker this year has been the ascension of the Ultimate Avengers title, simply called "The Ultimates". Terrific art by Bryan Hitch, coupled with the fearless, balls-out writing of Millar, has made for some spectacular storytelling. From the "Saving Private Ryan" opening of issue 1, to the thoroughly stunning domestic brawl of issue 6, this has been startling, challenging work.

Daredevil: Bendis again?! Smith, Mack, and Gale were great on this title, but let's face it; Bendis OWNS this book. I question the decision to "ultimatize" Daredevil, because this is a case where the current version is truly the only one you need. Every issue is a masterwork of plotting, and you get your surprises doled out amidst other plot twists and nuances that might not pay off for months. Brilliant, brilliant work.

Spider-Man: Tangled Web was a great idea, and JMS has been a masterstroke. With Kevin Smith coming aboard, this can only get better. Remember the mid-'90s, when the Clone Storyline made Spidey the bitch of the comic world? I've almost forgotten too. Of course, that little student film helped with the visibility this year.

The Fantastic Four: Waid. Wieringo. YES. The first issue, available for a criminally insane 9-cents, nailed things about the characters that I've wanted to see for years. I literally can't wait for the next issue. I have no idea when I last said that about this title. Maybe never.

Captain America: Talk about hitting the zeitgeist. Rieber and Cassaday are an electric duo, and their ability to tell the kinds of stories that they've been tackling in the current world climate is nothing short of amazing. Cassaday's art continues to inspire, and the overall narrative is unexpectedly gripping.

Captain Marvel: I hope it wins.

The Incredible Hulk: Bruce Jones=savior.

Thunderbolts: Always well drawn, Fabian Nicieza kept the early tradition of intricate, surprising stories. Although I hope the impending relaunch doesn't change things completely, it would be nice to see the initial cast achieve some kind of resolution.

Avengers: The mighty Geoff Johns steps in, and the first issue is tremendous. Busiek was good, but that Kang epic really ran out of steam for me. Johns has already proven himself on JSA, Flash and Hawkman; I'm totally intrigued about where this one will go. Looking good so far.

Marvel's been doing an awful lot of things right. By stretching with the MAX imprint and trying new things (like U-Decide), they're constantly keeping their name out there and doing their best to dominate conversation. Several other books that I haven't covered, like Iron Man, are also maintaining positive buzz with fresh infusions of talent.

Joe Quesada puts me in mind of a particularly good baseball GM. He knows where the players should play, and he knows where to get the talent to fill the holes. Eventually, we know that some of the big money talent will go off to other projects. The true test of Quesada's immortality will be how he follows up in the future. I can offer one authoritative assessment: Pretty damn good so far.

Back to Comics Convention



shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 2001 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.