© 2001 Top Shelf Productions

James Kochalka’s The Sketchbook Diaries

Review by:
Troy Brownfield


From: Top Shelf Productions

Rating: bananabananabananabanana

James Kochalka never fails to present us with interesting work. Whether he’s plying his trade as a musician or delivering his unique comics, he’s always pushing to get something different out of his chosen medium. I’m a big fan of Monkey vs. Robot, so I naturally looked forward to The Sketchbook Diaries.

The Sketchbook Diaries works almost as a “meta-comic”. We are told that Kochalka began keeping his four-panel strip a day diary in 1998, and that we can’t necessarily take every single incident as a truth. In form and function, it reminds me of Scott Dikkers’s superlative “Jim’s Journal”. That experiment in “anti-humor” could be alternately hilarious and insight as Jim commented on his uneventful days. Kochalka approaches his humor in a similar way, but his art goes in some decidedly different directions.

Kochalka chooses to represent himself as “Magic Elf Boy”, with wife Amy as, I suppose, a “Magic Elf Girl”. Other characters get odd interpretations, yet the cat remains the cat. The understated “cute” quality of the art disarms the reader; you don’t necessarily expect the childlike images to get drunk, have sex, and say “fuck”. When they do, it’s somewhat shocking, but equally honest and entertaining.

The bulk of the strips take an absurdist approach to life. Some are stridently straightforward and insightful. This manner of presentation could be tricky to pull off, but Kochalka does it extremely well.

In the end, there isn’t really an end. I assume that the diary, like life itself, is a work in progress. We should be happy that James Kochalka chooses to share some of that life with us.

Find out more about Top Shelf at www.topshelfcomix.com.

Return to the Comics Convention


Troy Brownfield is the Editor-in-Chief of Shotgun Reviews. He could have kept a diary of his time working for a certain catalog company, but the Russians have already written all the good prison novels.
Email Troy at psikotyk@aol.com.



shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 2001 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.