A Pleasant Surprise:
Shuck Comics #1-3
Review by:
Troy Brownfield

By: Rick Smith and Tania Menesse
More Information: www.sulfurstar.com

Rating: bananabananabananabanana

ShuckWhen I finished reading the first three issues of Shuck for the first time, I was mildly shocked. Had I really read a charming series of stories featuring a retired goat-headed demon, a cute little girl and a talking cat? Did I see a well-drawn, nicely produced story steeped in pagan mythos that came off as very kind-hearted? And did all of the characters speak in a dialect that is so internally consistent as to be somewhat amazing? I read them again. And I was right.

Shuck Comics will likely wind-up being mentioned alongside books like Bone as an under-the-radar success story. The production is of high quality, the stories are thoughtful, and the art is cleanly rendered. Rick Smith is a real talent. He both writes and draws the book (Tania Menesse is credited as a co-writer), and he does a fine job.

Shuck is a demon that apparently used to be in the business of guarding souls. Wearing an old man mask to hide his goat-faced nature, Shuck lives in a house next door to cute little Thursday Friday, her mom and her talking cat. Shuck misses his wife, Gaia, who apparently went away some time ago for reasons that come to light as the story progresses.

Obviously, the two most unique traits of the book are its dialectical dialogue form and the pervasive pagan imagery. I had the opportunity to ask Rick Smith about these particular influences:

On the dialogue, Rick says, "We had the plot down for the story and wanted a way to distinguish Shuck's world from our own. After a number of pints of beer I got frustrated with the challenge at hand and just started writing Shuck's and Thursday's dialogue as I heard it in my head. I finished most of the story. The next day, while editing, I was able to 'hear' the dialogue again. Finishing the story was a piece of cake after that. In the issues since, entering their world is as easy as picturing a conversation. People have said it sounds like Cajun, Afro-American, Yankee Vermont - you name it. Written slang often takes on a sound of its own in each reader's mind. Until the animated special, each reader will interpret and 'hear' the voices in their own way."

As far as the pagan themes, Rick noted, "I studied ancient pagan mythology as a youngster and much of my graduate coursework was focused on witchcraft and paganism. Shuck was invented sometime during the dotcom meltdown of 2000. A retired devil (horned god) functions well as an observer (and sometimes reluctant participant) in stories of pagan festivals, holidays."

Appropriately enough, the first issue covers Halloween. Shuck hosts a party for "deaduns" and there are quite a few touching moments. Honestly, I don't want to delve too much into the narrative of the issues, because they have a real charm and emotional resonance that I don't want to cheapen with rote plot explanations.

It's sufficient to say that Shuck deserves some wider attention. This is the kind of book that can find a core audience and thrive for years on simple stories, smartly told. Shuck Comics are definitely worth a look.

Return to the Comics Convention


Troy Brownfield is the Editor-in-Chief of Shotgun Reviews. His dad tried to convince him that he's just wearing an old man mask, but he ain't buyin' it. Email Troy at psikotyk@aol.com.


shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 2001 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.