The Dark is Rising:
Legion of Super-Heroes
The Great Darkness Saga

A DC Comics trade paperback review

By Troy Brownfield

Writer: Paul Levitz
Pencils: Keith Giffen (intro: Pat Broderick)
Inks: Larry Mahlstedt

More Info: www.dccomics.com

Rating: bananabananabananahalf bananahalf banana

Of one thing, there is no doubt: I love the Legion of Super-Heroes. I've been a fan for YEARS. While I have lapses in my collection that I have slowly but surely been filling out, I can quite readily affirm that I've been a fan for a long, long time. Webmaster Shawn and I spent much time as kids reading those DC Blue Ribbon Digest reprints. The main selling points for me were the sheer size of the team and their diverse alien backgrounds. It was implicit in the tales that no matter how bad things got, there was always a brighter future to look toward. Then came the Darkness . . .

It's hard to convey in retrospect how suffused with tension these issues were they originally appeared in issues #287, 290-294, and Annual #3, in 1982-1984. Recently released in trade form, likely due to the burgeoning popularity of the new series, this was a Legion epic that lived up to the name with scope and menace. From the teaser in #287, which indicates that things are not quite right on that barren, familiar world, to the coda of Annual #3, shock really did follow shock as the Legion struggled against the one menace that could have conceivably destroyed the universe. Who's strong enough to do that? Darkseid is.

I suppose at this point it's also hard to articulate the tension and surprise of that particular revelation, especially since the big guy is on the cover of the trade. Still, at the time, the impact was huge: the ultimate 20th century villain has returned to cover the galaxy in Darkness, and his plan will bring an army of 3 billion super-powered servants to his side. That's hardcore stuff for 1982, man! Levitz's writing is at full power, all doomy prophesizing and abject fear, while Giffen's fluid designs and style were on the comic cutting edge at the time. (I read a statistic in the back of an old DC Blue Ribbon Digest that reprinted Legion stories that showed that the readership had grown by about 50,000 during this era; imagine that today!)

One of the great things that Levitz, Giffen and the other manage to convey here is the Legion's tenacity. From the very beginning of the arc, they're continually getting their asses kicked by the machines and Servants of Darkness. And yet, and no point do they ever give in. They wonder, they ponder, and they worry, but they never stop. In fact, it can be argued that they don't technically ever win at all. The point, I would say, is in the striving. What is the light in the face of darkness? The light of heroism, obviously, but more likely the light of effort. As a wiser muppet than one once put, not trying equates quite readily to failure. The heroism displayed by the Legion and their allies in the face of ridiculously overwhelming odds is actually downright inspiring.

The Legion would go on to even darker days (Giffen's criminally overlooked '89 relaunch, the whole Zero Hour ending, etc.), but this story, this actual maturation of what the Legion was about, remains perhaps their definitive tale. It may be all about the Darkness, but it's surely the characters' brightest hour. You don't have to have 20+ years of Legion fandom in your life to know one thing: this one's a classic.

Troy Brownfield is the Editor-in-Chief of ShotgunReviews.com. He loves the fact that DC Direct has made Legion figures. Email him at psikotyk@aol.com

Return to the Comics Convention


shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 1999-2002 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.