X/1999
A Viz manga review

by Matt McConnel
More Info: www.viz.com

Rating: bananabananabananabanana


If you have ever seen anything from Clamp studio, you know exactly what to expect from X/1999. While it is odd that Viz continues to insist on translating and publishing X, while leaving its precursor Tokyo Babylon by the wayside, X remains a stand alone in both context and content. One can easily pick up the beginning of X, and enjoy it while being blissfully unaware of the existence of Babylon. Regardless, X and Tokyo Babylon represent a significant portion of Clamp's working portfolio, while both series are closed, they are incredibly long and complex (volume 7 has just been published here in the States).

There is little to be said about the art. Clamp always produces highly stylized and gorgeous artwork in the so-called Shojo or 'girl's style'. The strength is, as with much of Clamp's work, in the story. The short of it is that Kamui returns to Tokyo following the death of his mother. He left six years prior leaving his best friend as well as his best friend's sister. Understandably, these two are concerned and frightened when they see Kamui again at school and he blows them off. Fuma and Kotori (the brother and sister) also find out that strange things have been picking fights with Kamui. Fuma swore to protect Kamui, but Kamui seems to be perfectly capable of protecting himself with mysterious powers. Then Fuma begins to manifest these powers as well. Kamui is approached by individuals calling themselves the Seven Seals, nominal protectors of order in the world, and in direct opposition to the Seven Harbingers, those who would use their powers to destroy. The Seals are so concerned about marshaling their own forces and convincing Kamui to help them, against the Harbingers that they miss Fuma's jump in potential. Since Kamui and Fuma are linked somehow, Kamui's awaking to his own potential has also made Fuma come into his own. The Seven Harbingers immediately recruit Fuma, and that is only the end of the third volume.

Kotori has a part to play yet, but seems to be little more than the link between Fuma and Kamui. The intresting part comes when the reader figures out that the Seven Seals and Harbingers are in fact not, as one might expect, good and evil, but rather order and chaos, yin and yang. The Harbingers want to protect the Earth and its continued existence by causing global catastophy and pearing down the human race to the strongest and most intelligent that then can be taught, while the Seals want to preserve the human race and guide it towards a better future through subtlety and behind the scenes workings. Ok, well, it is more complex than that, chess to checkers really.

My own feelings towards X are mixed at best, while I like the art, and appreciate the storyline, I do not empathise with any of the characters save Subaru (stop laughing, it is his name), main character from Tokyo Babylon, who is revealed as one of the Seven Seals. He opposes one of the Harbingers, each Seal has their counterpart Harbinger like Fuma and Kamui, who is also a holdover from Babylon. The interplay between these two is great, but it is only a facet, and the actions of the rest of the cast hold little interest for me. Kamui is too cold, Fuma is too bull headed, Kotori is vapid, and the reasons for the two sides fighting seem a bit too clear cut. I find myself wishing that Kamui and Fuma would make everyone else get out of the sand box and go back to the classroom. But, owing to the complexity, that is impossible and I must content myself with the art and brief interludes with Subaru. However, as with my dislike of Robert Jordan (yup, hate him too), this is a very personal reaction, and should not color anyone else's opinion on the books. If anyone likes great art, and a devilishly complex story these are the books for you.

Matt McConnel is our anime guru. He says, "Dammit, Viz! Bring out Tokyo Babylon!".
Email Matt's grumpy ass here.

Return to the Comics Convention


shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 1999-2002 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.