Education in Action:
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
Vol. 1

An America's Best Comics trade paperback review

By Troy Brownfield

Writers: Alan Moore
Artist: Kevin O'Neill

More Info: www.wildstorm.com

Rating: bananabananabananabananabanana

If any man can lay claim to the title of the poet laureate of comics, that man is Britain's Alan Moore. Having spent the last few decades pushing the form into maturity with noted runs on "Swamp Thing" and "Miracleman", and the brilliant trifecta of "Watchmen", "V for Vendetta" and "From Hell", Moore's style emphasizes that comics can indeed be literature. Tying this concept together further, Moore and artist Kevin O'Neill released the hugely popular "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" a few years ago.

Pitting literary heroes Alan Quatermaine, Mina Murray, Dr. Henry Jekyl (and his other half), the Invisible Man, and Captain Nemo against Fu Manchu and Moriarity, the six-issue series was a rocket-ride through Victorian literature, infused with the energy of comics and the snide humor of the well-read. In fact, I can't figure out if English profs would consider this work anathema or a Godsend. I've got a Master's Degree, and I remember the contempt that some people had for comics. Of course, there were several profs who were fans themselves. Frankly, anything that would make today's audience slip back and read the original works has to be considered a positive. (I'll reserve judgment on the forthcoming film till I see it; I still think that shoehorning Dorian Gray and Tom Sawyer into the plot is fairly asinine.)

Moore and O'Neill have brought their "League" back for a second go-round; the first issue embraced a plot seed from the first series as Edgar Rice Burroughs mainstay John Carter and Gullivar team up to lead an army of their Martian allies against another alien faction. Sensing defeat, the aggressors head for the next convenient target: Earth. If this sounds vaguely reminiscent of something by H.G. Wells, collect your brown wedge and roll again.

The charm of new series, and the original "League" is the incorporation of all these Victorian stories into one epic pastiche. Nothing important is ignored; over the course of the main story and text pages from the first series, Moore found ways to work in 1800s advertisements, H.P. Lovecraft, Wells's Time Traveler, and even Dr. Syn. Setting a perfect counterpoint for all of this is O'Neill's art. Simultaneously richly detailed and suffused with pulp flavor, the visuals lend great flair to an already clever story. For a discerning reader looking for comics that engage both the eyes and the mind, "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" is a rare treat.

Troy Brownfield has two English degrees. His favorite work of "literature" as defined by "the canon" would have to be . . . ah screw it. His favorite books are "Watership Down", "The Stand", "The Big Sleep", "Tales of Mystery and Imagination", "The Dunwich Horror and Others", and "The Lord of The Rings". Email Troy at: psikotyk@aol.com

Return to the Comics Convention


shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 1999-2002 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.