Note: Actual cover not shown

The Justice Society Returns!
A DC trade paperback review

By Troy Brownfield

Writers: Various, including Geoff Johns, Mark Waid, Chuck Dixon, Ron Marz, James Robinson, David Goyer
Pencils: Various, including Stephen Sadowski, Russ Heath, Chris Weston, Peter Snejbjerg, Michael Bair, Keith Champagne

More Info: www.dccomics.com

Rating: bananabananabananahalf banana

By now, many people know that one of the best books published by DC Comics is JSA. The team's rich history stretches back over 60 years now. They were the first super-team in comics, and they continue to entertain to this day. Believe it or not, the lauch of the current series was seem by some as a dicey proposition. When the powers that be at DC finally decided to give the team a title again in 1999, they went all-out by promoting a Justice Society Returns! event. Though the new ongoing would feature a mix of old and young heroes, the event put out a flood of specials that teamed up two members of the group to fight elements of a larger menace; two bookend volumes began and completed the story. The creative talents amassed to handle the assignments were formidable, with some writers taking on the '40s counterparts for the modern books they wrote (Waid wrote the Flash segment for example). It was a successful undertaking, announcing the return of the classic team in a big way.

And now, the complete story is finally available in trade paperback. All nine issues can be found herein, as well as two short from various Secret Files and Origins specials. What we've got then, is an outstanding pastiche of Golden Age heroic action, rendered by some of the best contemporary art and writing talents in the field.

One of the highlights is the Smash Comics installment. Hourman and Dr. Mid-Nite go to Scotland pursuing one portion of the overarching mystical menace. In the hands of writer Tom Peyer and artists Sadowski and Bair, this turns into a dervish of an action yarn with Dr. Mid-Nite's own Hootie playing a great part. The conflicts of Hourman's character are well-handled, and Sadowski and Bair show off the chops that they would bring to the then-nascent ongoing title.

An added highlight is that many of the creators involved work in other Golden Age heroes in the various stories, so that by the time the final confrontation with villain Stalker arrives, we've got an armada of old-school heroes ready to administer an epic beat-down. Fittingly, it's Hourman who again shines. Hourman has always been one of my sentimental favorite characters, and he's well-used. As are all of the characters involved. Justice Society Returns! helped to prove that just because a character has history, it doesn't mean it can't be fresh. That's something that the regular series continues to prove on a monthly basis.


Troy Brownfield is the Editor-in-Chief of ShotgunReviews.com. Email him at
psikotyk@aol.com

Return to the Comics Convention


shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 1999-2004 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.