Still Terrific :
JSA: Fair Play

DC trade paperback review by :
Troy Brownfield


Writer: Geoff Johns
Pencils:
Rags Morales, Stephen Sadowski, Peter Snejbjerg, Javier Saltares, Derec Aucoin
Inks: Michael Bair, Keith Champagne, Peter Snejbjerg, Ray Kryssing, David Meikis, Christian Alamy
Colorists: John Kalisz, Tom McGraw
Letters: Ken Lopez, Kurt Hathaway


More Info: www.dccomics.com

Rating: bananabananabananahalf banana

Anyone who's familiar with the site knows that I'm predisposed to give JSA a good review. I'm a big fan, and not just because I have long standing affection for the titular team. I've been happy from the start with how the various creators have brought us a straight-forward, irony-free super-hero team. The feel of the book is hard to describe, but it evokes simultaneously nostalgia and excitement. Bottom line: The people who can't make super-hero books work just aren't trying hard enough. Fans of the JSA can tell you that the book usually looks incredible and effortless at the same time. All involved seem to genuinely love what they're doing.

Which brings us to Geoff Johns. Johns usually partners with David Goyer on this title; however, during this strech (issues 26-31 and Secret Files & Origins #2), Goyer was doing his tiny little day-job of screenwriter and director full-time (If you haven't heard, Goyer's supposed to write and helm Blade III, as well as writing a new Batman film for director Christopher Nolan). Not to worry; readers of The Flash, Avengers, Stars and S.T.R.I.P.E. and more will tell you that Johns is just fine on his own. This time around, the major story takes an inversion of that old ploy of "villain-traps-heroes-in-gladitorial-situation" and mixes it up with Fight Club.

Johns plays the pop-culture juggling of the script just right. These situations (electrified chess between Mr. Terrific and Dr. Mid-Nite; Hawkman and Sand versus Man-Bats in the jungle) are as much Wild Wild West (and I mean the good one where Dr. Loveless was a midget) as Fight Club. While it's action-packed, it also builds the characters, showing how they use their respective strengths to avoid deathtraps.

The other stories handle a variety of topics from electing a new team leader to romantic entanglements in the group to an appearance by Captain Marvel. Sand has a prophetic dream that essentially set up the next two years of stories. Batman drops by. Star-Spangled Kid and Jakeem Thunder face Solomon Grundy in a "Last Laugh" crossover that deepens the young J.K.'s character. All this, and a surprise new member joins by the end.

Every issue collected in the volume is brilliantly rendered by some of the best artists in comics today. Rags Morales is a particular stand-out, showing off the chops that led to his regular Hawkman gig. I still miss the work of Stephen Sadowski, also showcased here. The two issues by Snejbjerg demonstrate a different style; his use of darkness and shading is especially appropriate to the Grundy and Batman tales.

All told, JSA continues to be one of the shining lights of the DC line. If you want old-school super-hero action, you won't find a better book than JSA.


Troy Brownfield is the Editor-in-Chief of Shotgun Reviews. Here's hoping that Johns uses some of that "DC Exclusive" clout to get some modern JSA figures made. You listening, Georg? Email Troy at psikotyk@aol.com.

Return to the Comics Convention


shotgun reviews
| the big question | review rack | feature forum | rasslin' ring | comics convention | shotgun press | contact | links
home | masthead | sponsors | email: psikotyk@aol.com
© 1999-2002 Shotgun Reviews - All rights reserved.